Roof Damage After a Storm: What Insurance Covers and What It Often Ignores

Storms don’t discriminate. Whether you’re managing a hospital campus, school district, manufacturing facility, or a portfolio of multi-family units, severe weather can inflict serious roof damage that demands immediate attention. But when it comes time to file an insurance claim for roof storm damage, the fine print in your policy might leave you with more questions than coverage.

This article breaks down the often overlooked realities of roof storm damage claims, helping commercial and multi-family property stakeholders understand their responsibilities, common insurance pitfalls, and how to get a fair settlement.

CONTACT US NOW!

Common Roof Storm Damage: More Than Just Missing Shingles

Roof storm damage comes in all shapes and sizes. High winds can tear away roofing membranes or lift flashing. Hail can puncture built-up roofs and leave long-term vulnerabilities. Debris can cause hidden fractures or dislodge key components. Over time, these issues can lead to leaks, microbial contamination, and compromised structural integrity.

Some of the most common damage types we see after a storm include:

• Torn or punctured roofing membranes (especially in flat commercial roofs)
• Lifted or missing flashing around vents, skylights, and HVAC systems
• Impact damage from hail or debris that compromises roof surfaces
• Pooling water due to displaced drainage systems
• Hidden moisture intrusion, which can lead to microbial contamination and rot

Water-related losses are among the most common and costly, and require precise documentation and specialized drying processes.

What Your Policy May Cover (and What It Likely Ignores)

According to the Office of Program Policy Analysis and Government Accountability (OPPAGA), insurance carriers have a long-standing pattern of denying or underpaying claims, particularly for weather-related losses. Commercial policies often cover direct physical damage from wind, hail, or fire. However, they may exclude or severely limit coverage for:

• Cosmetic damage, even when it impacts long-term performance
• Pre-existing wear and tear, even if exacerbated by storm impact
• Microbial contamination, which insurers often try to classify as a maintenance issue
• Partial damage to a roof section, forcing owners to patch rather than replace

The result? Many commercial policyholders are forced to settle for band-aid solutions while still absorbing future repair costs out-of-pocket.

Why Documentation Is Everything

Insurance carriers scrutinize every claim and delay or deny them whenever possible. That’s why comprehensive documentation is your first line of defense.

Immediately after a storm, it’s essential to:

• Take detailed photos from multiple angles, especially of damage to roofing materials, flashings, and drainage systems
• Request a professional inspection to detect less obvious issues like internal moisture or structural displacement
• Create a timeline of events, including the date/time of the storm and the discovery of damage
• Preserve damaged materials whenever feasible for future inspection

These actions can significantly strengthen your claim, especially when dealing with complex property types like healthcare facilities or apartment buildings.

When the Carrier Says "No" to Roof Storm Damage Claims

Denials and lowball offers are more common than most realize. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) notes that disputes over claims payment and delays are consistently among the top consumer complaints each year.

Examples we’ve encountered include:

• A commercial claim denied due to “pre-existing conditions,” even though the damage clearly occurred during a known hail event
• A multi-family roof claim paid out for just one section of a contiguous membrane, leaving the remainder vulnerable
• Claims drastically undervalued because the insurer used outdated pricing models or unqualified inspectors

Experts like Jay M. Feinman, author of Delay, Deny, Defend, argue that these tactics are systemic and designed to wear down claimants. Public adjusters push back by leveling the playing field.

The Public Adjuster's Role: Advocating for Full Restoration

Public adjusters are licensed professionals who represent you, the policyholder, not the insurance company. Our job is to uncover the entire scope of damage, create a claim package with proper evidence, and negotiate directly with the carrier.

Here’s how public insurance adjusters help ensure you receive a fair settlement:

• Conduct in-depth inspections that reveal damage often missed in insurance company reports
• Leverage certifications and industry standards, like our IICRC training in Water Damage and Structural Drying, to support claim details
• Present line-itemed, policy-compliant estimates that reflect the real cost of materials and labor
• Push for full roof replacement when a patch would violate code or compromise building performance

Experts often emphasize the crucial role public adjusters play in holding insurers accountable.

Whether it’s microbial contamination from water intrusion, smoke and fire damage from lightning strikes, or commercial roof systems weakened by debris, public insurance adjusters aim for full scope restoration. Not partial. Not cosmetic.

Final Thoughts on Roof Storm Damage Claims

Insurance carriers have a well-documented history of denying, delaying, or severely underpaying roof storm damage claims, especially in commercial and complex property settings. The more you understand your policy’s limitations and your responsibilities as a policyholder, the better you can protect your assets after a storm.

Here at Velocity Insurance Public Adjusters, we can help you navigate the complex world of insurance claims with confidence. If you’ve experienced roof damage or are concerned about what your policy actually covers, schedule a call for a free claim and policy review today. Let us help you turn a frustrating claim process into a strategic recovery plan.